All posts

Commission on a first-order only, or on repeat orders too

Pay on the first-order only if a creator's job is to introduce new buyers and your own store brings them back. Pay on repeat orders too, usually at a lower rate, if your product is bought again and again and the first order is a small trial. Whichever you choose, creators should know it before they post, because it changes what a customer is worth to them.

The case for the first-order only

A creator introduces someone to your brand. After that first order, the customer has your product, your packaging and your emails. If they come back, a lot of the reason is you.

Paying again on the third and fourth order means paying for work your store already did. Stopping at the first order keeps commission tied to the one thing a creator clearly caused: a new customer.

It is also easier to budget. Each new customer costs you one commission at one rate, and you can set that beside what an ad costs to find the same buyer.

The case for repeat orders

Some products are used up and bought again: coffee, skincare, supplements, pet food. The first order is often a small trial, and the customer's worth shows up over the following months.

Pay only on that small first order and a creator earns very little for bringing you someone who might spend hundreds over a year. A higher first-order rate can make up for it, but it gets expensive fast, as the example further down shows.

There is also the creator who keeps posting. A customer who sees the same person use your product every week is being reminded, and some of their reorders come from that. Paying on repeat orders rewards the reminder as well as the introduction.

Which repeat orders reach a creator

A repeat order can only earn commission if your program ties it to a creator. That happens in one of two ways. The order carries a creator's code or came in through their link, or your program keeps each customer with the creator who first referred them, so their later orders count with no new click.

Two cases come up often. A returning customer types the same creator's code again. Or a customer who first came through one creator later finds a different creator's code and uses that one. Under first-order only, neither order earns anything. Under a repeat rule, both do, and the second means paying a new creator for a customer someone else found.

Settle whether you'll pay for that second case before you pick a rule, and write the answer into your terms.

What each rule pays the creators you have

First order only pays best for creators who keep reaching people who have never heard of you, such as a creator whose audience turns over quickly or who posts across several platforms.

Paying on repeat orders suits creators with a smaller following who talk about you for months. Their audience buys, then buys again, and the creator earns each time. A creator like that may care less about the headline rate than about whether a customer they bring in keeps earning them something.

Look at the creators who sell for you now, notice which kind they are, and pick the rule that keeps them.

One customer, six orders

Say a creator brings you a customer whose first order is $40. That customer reorders every two months with the creator's code, five more times in the year, at $40 each: six orders and $240.

At 20 percent on the first-order only, the creator earns $8 from that customer. At 20 percent on every order, they earn $48, and the repeat rule costs you $40 more for this one customer.

Turn it around. A 10 percent rate on every order pays the creator $24 over the year. Matching that with a first-order rule would take a 60 percent rate on the $40 first order. Paying the same on the first order alone would take a rate you would never offer, so for a product people reorder, a modest rate on every order is the only way to match it.

Changing the rule later

Moving from repeat orders to first-order only cuts what some creators earn, sometimes by a lot. Announce it with a start date at least a month out and the reason for it, so nobody finds out from a smaller balance.

Moving the other way is a raise, and creators will welcome it. That makes first-order only the safer place to start if you have no reorder numbers yet: widening the rule later is easy news to give.

Once you've decided, put the rule in your terms next to how commission is worked out, and repeat it in the welcome message.

What last year's reorders tell you

Pull every customer whose first order came through a creator's code or link in the last twelve months, and count how many ordered again. If few did, first-order only costs your creators little, and in Seedr it is one choice in Settings, which stops commission after a customer's first order. If many did, work out what a repeat rule would have paid on those same orders, and set that figure beside what those customers spent before you decide.