All posts

Flat fee, commission, or both: how to pay a creator

A flat fee buys content you want to own and use. Commission pays for sales. A smaller fee plus commission covers the case in between, a creator whose work you want but whose sales you can't predict yet, and it shares the risk when neither of you knows how a post will do.

What a flat fee buys

A flat fee is a fixed price for agreed work: one video, a set of photos, a post on a given date. You pay it whether the post sells anything or not.

That makes sense when the content itself is what you want. A clip you can run as an ad, photos for your product pages, a demo you can send to wholesale buyers. You'd pay a photographer for those, and a creator who makes them is doing similar work.

If you pay a fee, agree in writing what you get and where you may use it. A video for the creator's feed is a different deal from a video you can run as a paid ad for a year, and the price should differ with it. Settle that before they film.

When commission alone is fair

Commission alone is fair when the creator is doing what they'd do anyway. They already like the product, they mention it in a story, they put the link in their bio. The effort is small, and the reward grows with the sales.

It stops being fair when you ask for real production on a deadline. A scripted video with a set date, paid only if it sells, puts all the risk on the creator. Good creators will say no, and the ones who say yes may rush it.

A useful test: if you'd be annoyed to get nothing back from the work, the creator would be too. That work deserves a fee.

How a mix works

A mix is a smaller fee for the work of making the content, plus commission on what it sells. The fee tells the creator you value the effort. The commission keeps them interested in sales once the post is up, so they answer questions in the comments and mention the code again.

Keep the fee modest and the rate the same as everyone else's, or close to it. A large fee puts you back to paying mostly up front. A rate well above your usual one gets talked about, and other creators will ask why.

What each asks of your cash flow

A fee leaves before any result. You might pay half when the creator agrees and half on delivery, but the money goes out before you know whether the post works.

Commission trails the sale. You pay it after the order is in, after any hold period has passed, on your next pay day. By then the buyer's money is in your account, so commission comes out of revenue rather than ahead of it.

If cash is tight, that timing matters more than the total. A fee you can afford in a good month may not fit in a slow one, while commission moves with sales.

One video, three offers

Say you want one short video from a creator, and you have three offers in mind:

  • A flat fee of $400.
  • Commission only, at 15 percent.
  • A $150 fee plus 10 percent commission.

If the video drives $2,000 in sales after discounts in its first month, the fee costs you $400, commission only $300, and the mix $350.

If it drives $500, the fee still costs $400, commission only $75, and the mix $200.

Commission only stays cheapest until sales reach about $2,667, where it matches the fee. Above that the flat fee is the cheapest of the three. The mix is never the cheapest of the three on these numbers. What it buys is a softer landing: if the video sells only $500, the mix costs $200 against $400 for the fee, and the creator is still paid for the work.

Matching the deal to the creator

Use what you know about each one. Someone new, whose sales you can't guess, suits the mix: they're paid for the work, and you aren't betting the whole amount on a post you haven't seen. Someone who has sold well for months suits commission, with a better rate if they've earned it.

Someone whose content you want for ads suits a flat fee with usage written into the agreement, even if they never sell a thing through their own link.

Whichever you offer, state the commission base before the first sale. Seedr works commission out on the order's subtotal once discounts come off, with shipping and tax left outside it, which is the base the example above uses. Ask your accountant how to record fees and commission before you pay the first fee.

Where the two offers meet

Take the next piece of content you plan to ask for. Write down the fee you'd pay for it and the rate you'd offer instead, divide the fee by the rate, and you have the sales figure where the two cost the same. If you expect the post to sell more than that, offer the fee.