All posts

How many creators to start a program with

Fewer than you think. Work out how many creators your product budget allows and how many your spare hours allow, then start with the smaller of the two. In the example below, a $600 budget would cover 20 creators, but six hours a month only covers 8.

The first limit is product

Every creator in a first round costs you product and shipping, whether or not they post. Decide how much you're willing to give away this month with nothing guaranteed back, and divide it by what one send costs you.

Count what the product costs you to make or buy, never its shelf price. A $35 serum that costs you $9 is a $9 gift, before the shipping label and the box.

The second limit is your time

Each creator takes time: finding them, checking their account, writing to them, packing the parcel, following up, replying when they post and keeping notes.

That's easy to underestimate. Twenty creators can mean twenty threads running at once, each with its own questions, while you're also packing customer orders.

Plan for the hours you have in an ordinary week. If that's two, plan for two, and treat a quiet week as a bonus. Then time your first creator from first message to final note, and swap your guess for the real figure before you plan the next round.

Eight creators from $600 and six hours

Say you can spend $600 on a first round. Each send costs you $20 in product, $8 in shipping and $2 in packaging, $30 in all. On budget alone, that's 20 creators.

Now time. Say each creator takes about 45 minutes across the round, from first message to final note, and you have 6 hours to spare this month. That's room for 8.

Start with 8. Those sends use $240 of the budget, which leaves $360 for second sends to the creators who post, and for the replacement parcel in the next section.

Hold back one replacement

In any round, a parcel may go missing or arrive damaged. Sending a replacement quickly matters more than the product cost, because a creator who waited three weeks for nothing is unlikely to post about the second one.

On the example's figures, setting aside one send's worth, $30, covers a single replacement without touching the money for second sends. Ask the creator to tell you when the parcel arrives, so a lost one shows up in days instead of weeks.

A small group shows you more

With eight creators, you can read every post, every comment thread and every message. You notice which product they reached for and what their audience asked about.

With forty, you skim. The patterns are still there, but you're too busy packing to see them, and the creators who needed a nudge or a quick answer don't get one.

A small group also lets you fix your process cheaply. If your packaging arrives crushed or your instructions confuse people, you find out with eight parcels instead of forty.

Change one thing at a time

Within a small first round, vary one thing on purpose. You might send to a few customers and a few creators who've never heard of you, or try two different products with the same kind of creator.

Keep everything else steady. If the product, the message and the type of creator all change at once, you won't know which one made the difference.

Signs it's time to widen

Widen the program once the first round has taught you something you can repeat. Two good signs: you've found a few creators you want to keep working with, and you kept up with the follow-ups without letting messages sit.

Give the posts time to appear first, which for many products means a few weeks after delivery. A round judged the week the parcels land looks worse than it was.

Grow in steps. If eight went well, try fifteen. Each step should be small enough that your follow-up doesn't slip.

A monthly ceiling

Pick a monthly number of sends you can pack and follow up on, and treat it as a ceiling so a busy month doesn't push it up by habit. If you send through Seedr, Base allows 20 sends in a calendar month, so a first round of 8 plus a replacement leaves room for second sends inside the same month.

Decide in advance what happens to creators who don't post. Sending them nothing more is fair, and it keeps the product for the ones who do.

The number before the names

Before you choose a single creator, write down the hours you can give the program over the next month and the minutes one creator takes you from first message to final note. Turn the hours into minutes, then divide by the minutes one creator takes. That's the most you should start with, whatever the budget says.