All posts

How to check a creator before you send product

The follower count is the least useful number on a creator's profile. What tells you whether a gift will pay off is who follows them, what those people write in the comments, how past brand posts landed, and how the creator answers your first message. Those checks take about ten minutes a name, need nothing but the public profile, and keep you from sending product to an audience that will never buy from you.

Does the audience look like your buyer?

Open a few of the accounts that comment and like, and ask whether they look like people who would buy your product: a similar age and set of interests, living in a country you ship to, talking about the things your customers talk about.

A creator can make lovely videos for an audience that will never order from you. A home cooking account followed mostly from overseas is a poor match for a bakery that only delivers locally, however good the videos are.

You can also ask the creator for a screenshot of their audience breakdown. One who sends it without fuss is used to working with brands.

Read the comments like a buyer would

Comments say more than likes. Scroll through the last ten or so posts and read what people actually write.

Good signs are questions about products, people tagging friends, and replies from the creator that show they know their followers. Warning signs are pages of single emoji and the same short praise repeated by different accounts.

Notice whether the creator replies at all. One who talks to their audience is more likely to answer questions about your product once the post goes up.

Look at past brand posts

Find two or three posts where the creator worked with a brand. Look at how the product was shown, whether it felt like part of their normal content, and how the audience reacted compared with their regular posts.

Then check the disclosure. A clear label, such as the platform's paid partnership tag or a plain "gifted" or "ad" in the caption, shows a creator who takes it seriously. A brand post with no label at all is a risk to you as well as to them. How to ask creators to disclose a partnership covers what a clear label looks like and what to do when one is missing.

Count the brand posts too. On an account where every other post is sponsored, the audience has learned to scroll past them.

Signs of bought followers

Bought followers make an account look bigger than its real reach, and two checks catch most of it.

Look at follower growth, if the platform or the creator can show it. Steady growth is normal. A jump of thousands in a day with no viral post behind it is not.

Then open a sample of followers. Accounts with no posts and a string of numbers for a name are often fake. A few turn up on any account, but a large share of them is a problem.

Two accounts, compared by views

Say two creators reply to your message. Creator A has 50,000 followers, and their last 12 videos averaged 1,000 views. Creator B has 8,000 followers, and their last 12 videos averaged 2,400 views.

A's videos reach about 2 percent of their followers. B's reach 30 percent.

There's no fixed rule for the right percentage, and it varies by platform. What matters here is that B's videos reach more people than A's in plain numbers, even though A has over six times the followers. B looks like the better gift, and A's follower count deserves a closer look before you send anything.

How they answer your first message

The reply is part of the check. A creator who answers clearly, asks a sensible question about the product and sends an address without fuss is likely to be easy to work with.

Be wary when a no-strings gift offer comes back with a fee, or with a request for several products before trying one. Neither rules a creator out, but both tell you what working together will be like.

Write down why you said yes

Keep a line on each creator you approve: why they fit, what you checked and anything that worried you. After a round, those notes show which checks predicted who actually posted, and which ones you can stop doing.

If your gifts go out as orders in your store, the note can sit on the order as well. Keeping track of who got free product covers that setup.

Five names in one sitting

Take the next five creators on your list and run the same checks on all of them at once: audience, comments, past brand posts, a follower sample, and average views against followers. Side by side, the weak one is usually obvious within a few minutes, and you send four parcels instead of five.