How to choose a creator affiliate app for Shopify
Run seven tests during the free trial: who gets credit for an awkward order, what commission is a percentage of, how a payout gets recorded, what a gift looks like in your orders, what the bill does in a big month, what a creator sees when they sign in, and what stays behind when you uninstall. Most need only yourself as a test creator and two orders.
Seedr is our app, built by Influxx, an agency that runs creator programs for Shopify brands. After each test we say how Seedr handles it. Run the same tests on any app you're considering.
Does the right creator get the sale?
Add yourself as a creator. On your phone, open your link and buy one product with Buy it now, which skips the cart. Then open the link on your phone again, close it, and buy the same product on your laptop after searching your store. Open both orders in the app.
The first order shows whether the app can credit a sale when the cart never got tagged. The second shows whether it is honest about what it can't see: nothing on that laptop connects the order to you, so an app that credits it anyway is guessing.
Seedr tags the cart with the creator's code through a theme app embed, alongside a Shopify web pixel. When a cart was never tagged, as in the Buy it now order, it checks Shopify's own record of the visit and can still credit the creator whose link brought the buyer in. An order with no trace of a source is labeled Direct, so every source it shows is one it actually saw.
What is the commission a percentage of?
Put a discount, shipping and tax on one test order and work out the commission yourself before you look. Say the order is $60 of product with a $6 discount, $5 shipping and $4 tax, and the rate is 10 percent. On the product after the discount, the commission is $5.40. If the app shows $6.30, it is paying on shipping and tax as well.
While you're there, give your test creator their own rate and check which rate the app uses.
Seedr works commission out on the subtotal that's left once discounts come off, and leaves shipping and taxes out of it. It uses the creator's own rate first, then their group's rate, then your store default. If you'd rather reward only new buyers, a setting limits commission to each customer's first order.
How does a payout get recorded?
Approve the test commission and pay yourself. Note what the app asks for: bank details, a connected payment account, or just a record that the money went out. Sign in as the creator and check the balance dropped by exactly what you paid. Then refund the second order and watch its commission.
With Seedr, the money moves through whatever you pay people with now, PayPal or a bank transfer for example, and you mark the payout in the app. You keep control of the cash, the creator's balance follows your record, and you never collect bank details. A hold period, counted from the order date, keeps a new commission waiting so a refund usually arrives before it can be approved.
What does a gift look like in your orders?
Send yourself one product as a gift through the app, then check Shopify for an order, for stock off the right variant, and for a place in your usual packing queue. A gift that exists only inside the app never reaches your inventory or your order history.
Seedr creates each gift as a $0 order in your store, so it is picked, shipped and tracked from the same queue as a customer's. A creator can't have a second send started while the first is still in your warehouse, and a send Shopify refuses doesn't count toward Base's monthly limit.
What does the bill do in a big month?
Read the pricing and ask what you'd pay if creators sold three times as much next month. An app that charges per order or takes a share of sales costs most in your best months.
Seedr bills a flat plan price through Shopify, whatever you sell. Base, at $29 a month, covers 100 active creators and 20 sends in a calendar month. Full, at $79 a month, has no cap on either and adds CSV import of creators, recording a sale by hand, and Commission audit, which reads the last seven days of Shopify orders and lists anything that disagrees with what Seedr recorded. The audit only reads, so it can't change anything. The 14-day trial runs on whichever plan you start with.
What does a creator see?
Sign in as your test creator on a phone. Can you find the link, the code, the two test sales and the balance without asking anyone? A creator who can't find their numbers will message you for them.
In Seedr, creators sign in to a portal that shows those four things. The app works inside Shopify with nothing outside it to connect, though you do turn on its app embed in your theme.
What stays when you uninstall?
Find out before you depend on an app. A discount code stored in Shopify keeps working at checkout after the app is gone, so check where the codes live, and how long the app keeps your data.
When you uninstall Seedr, tracking stops and the creator portal closes. Orders, discount codes and customer data remain in your Shopify store, and Seedr deletes its own copy of the store's data 30 days later.
Two test orders decide most of it
Pick the app you're leaning toward, add yourself as a creator and place the two orders from the first test. Every other test runs off those two orders, so the whole list fits inside one trial. If Seedr is the one you're testing, start the trial on the plan you expect to need.