How to follow up after you gift a product
Wait until the creator has had long enough to use the product, then ask what they thought of it, not when they'll post. One note is usually enough, with one lighter one a few weeks later if the first goes unanswered. Silence after that is an answer, and you can take it kindly.
Time it from delivery
Count the wait from the day the parcel arrives. A note that lands while the box is still in transit reads as impatient, and one sent on delivery day gives the creator nothing to say yet.
So watch the tracking. In Seedr a gift is an order in your own store, which puts its tracking in your order list next to everything else you ship.
How long to wait after that depends on how long the product takes to judge. A snack or a candle can be tried the day it lands. Skincare or a pair of running shoes may need a couple of weeks of use. A useful test is to ask when a customer could first tell a friend whether it's any good, and to write a little after that. If you're unsure, a few days late is better than a few days early, because a creator who hasn't opened the box yet has to admit it.
What the first note says
Keep it short and about them, with one open question they can answer in a line:
"Hi [name], hope the [product] arrived in one piece. Once you've given it a proper try, I'd love to hear how it went, good or bad. No rush at all."
There's no mention of posting and no hashtag. If you offered the gift with no obligation, a follow-up that asks about content quietly takes that back, and the creator will notice.
Treat the feedback as the return
Honest feedback from someone who makes content for a living is worth having on its own. Creators notice what a regular customer wouldn't think to mention, such as how the packaging looked on camera or which feature their audience asked about.
If a reply contains criticism, thank them and take it seriously. A creator who tells you the sizing runs small has done you a favor, and one who sees you listened is far more likely to work with you again.
Keep a line of notes on what each creator says. One comment about a stiff zipper is one person's view. When the same comment comes back from several creators, it's about the product.
If a reply is vague, such as "loved it", one more question is fair: what would they change, or who would they give it to? The second answer is usually the one you can act on.
Twelve pairs of shoes, nine answers
Say you gift running shoes to 12 creators and send each the note above two weeks after delivery. Nine reply. Four of those nine mention the same thing: the shoes run about half a size small.
That's a size chart change you can make before the next production run, from people who wore the shoes on real runs, and it cost you nothing beyond the gifts. Three of the nine also posted without being asked, and they're the first three to offer a code and commission. The three who never replied get one more short note, and then nothing.
When a post goes up
Thank them quickly, and mention a moment in it you liked so the thanks is clearly about their post. Ask before you share or reuse it. Permission to post on their own account isn't permission to post on yours, and a creator who's asked first is happier to say yes.
This is also the natural time to offer more: a link and code with commission, or the next product before it launches. A creator who posted with nothing asked of them is a strong candidate for a paid arrangement.
When nothing gets posted
Some gifts never produce a post, and that's part of gifting. The creator may not have liked the product, or simply had no time that month.
Never send a reminder about posting for a no-strings gift. If they answered your question about the product, you already got something useful from the gift. If they didn't answer at all, one more short note a few weeks later is fine, and after that you leave it.
Keep the door open all the same. A creator who didn't post about this product may be exactly right for a different one next season, and they'll remember that you didn't chase.
Your question for each recent gift
Look at the gifts that have arrived over the last couple of weeks. Beside each creator's name, write the one question you'll ask about the product and the date it will have had enough use to answer, then send the first note to whoever has had theirs longest.