How to set a creator commission rate
Work out what an average creator sale leaves you after every cost, then pick a rate that hands the creator a share of it and still leaves you a margin you'd be glad to see on every order. Your own numbers set the ceiling; what other brands pay tells you very little about your costs.
Start with what a sale is worth to you
Take an average order and subtract everything it costs you to fill it: the product, packaging, any shipping you pay for, payment fees, and any discount the buyer used. What's left is what the sale is worth before commission.
Use real figures from last month's orders. A guess here gives you a rate that looks fine on paper and loses money in practice.
A $60 order, costed
Take a store whose average order is $60. The product costs $18 to make, packaging and shipping come to $9, and payment fees are about $2, which leaves $31.
If the buyer used a 10 percent creator code, they paid $54, and the sale is worth $25 before commission.
At 20 percent of what the buyer paid, the creator earns $10.80 and you keep $14.20. At 30 percent, they earn $16.20 and you keep $8.80. Somewhere around 46 percent, the sale earns you nothing at all, and every point you set below that line is your margin on a creator order.
Decide what the margin has to cover
What you keep pays for your time, your other marketing, and the product you gave creators to get them started. It also has to leave a profit.
Two things make a higher rate easier to afford. The first is repeat buying: if customers a creator brings in tend to come back, the first sale is worth more than it looks. The second is newness: a sale to someone who had never heard of you is worth more than one to a regular who happened to find a code.
If either is true for you, you can afford a more generous rate on the first order. Paying commission on first orders only puts the money where creators actually found you a customer, and stops paying for orders a regular would have placed anyway.
Choose what the rate is a percentage of
Decide which number the rate applies to before you announce it. A common rule is what the buyer paid for the products after discounts, with shipping and tax left out, because that money covers shipping and tax rather than your product.
Write the rule into your terms and tell creators before their first sale. A creator who expects 20 percent of the total and gets 20 percent of the subtotal will feel shortchanged, even though both of you did the sum correctly.
How the rate reads to a creator
A creator sees the rate before anything else about your program. Too low, and the good ones won't bother. Too high, and you've set a number you'll want to cut later, which costs more trust than starting a little lower would have.
A plain rate is easier to explain than a clever one. To reward the creators who sell most, give them their own higher rate and leave the base rate simple.
You can also set a rate for a group, for example creators who make video, without touching anyone else's. Seedr looks for a creator's own rate first, then their group's, then the store default, so one standout can earn more while everyone else keeps their deal.
Test it on last month's orders
Before you announce a rate, run last month's orders through it. Pretend creators had driven them and work out what you would have paid. If the total makes you wince, the rate is too high. If it barely registers, you probably have room to be more generous.
Then pick a rate you're sure you can hold for a year. Creators remember a cut long after they've forgotten a raise.
When to change the rate
Review the rate once or twice a year. Look at what creator sales actually cost you after refunds and gifting, and whether the creators you most want to keep are still posting.
If a few creators carry most of your sales, raise their rates and leave the rest. If your costs have gone up, change the rate for new creators first and give existing ones plenty of notice before theirs moves. Give a reason and a date with any change, so nobody first learns of it from a statement.
Your own break-even rate
Pull last month's average order value and write every cost against it, in the same order as the $60 example. Divide what's left by what the buyer paid. That's your break-even rate, and a rate well under it is one you can keep.