All posts

How to tell if a creator is worth what you pay them

A creator is worth what you pay them if, over three months or more, the margin their sales left you after refunds is bigger than everything they cost: product at cost, shipping, any fee and their commission. Below that line they are costing you money, though content you can reuse may still make them worth keeping.

Everything goes in the cost column

Start with product. Count every item you sent the creator at what it cost you to make or buy, not at its shelf price, and add the shipping you paid on each parcel. Replacements for lost parcels count too.

Then add any flat fee you paid for a post or a video, and all the commission their sales earned, whether you've paid it yet or not. If they're owed it, it's a cost. If your program pays on repeat orders, the commission on reorders from customers this creator found belongs here as well, because it is part of what keeping them costs.

Leave the buyer's discount out of this column. It already lowered what the order brought in, so it shows up on the other side, and counting it twice makes every creator with a code look worse than they are.

Use margin, not revenue

Revenue is the easy number, and it makes almost everyone look good. A creator who brought in $1,000 of sales didn't leave you $1,000. They left you what was over once the product in those orders was paid for.

Take each creator's sales after refunds and work out the gross margin on them, using your own cost of goods. If your margin varies a lot between products, use the products that creator actually sold rather than a store average.

Why one month is too short

The timing works against the creator in the first month. You pay for the product the week you send it, while the sales it leads to can arrive weeks later, as the post gets found, shared and saved. A first month can show a creator deep in the red who comes out well ahead by the third.

Three months is a fairer window for most products. If your buyers take a long time to decide, or the creator posts less often, give it longer. And judge on totals across the window, rather than the best or worst week inside it.

One creator's quarter, added up

Say you sent a creator two products over the quarter, each costing you $30 plus $10 shipping, for $80. You paid one flat fee of $200 for a video. Their link and code brought in 25 orders at $60 after discounts, $1,500 in all, and $150 of that was refunded, leaving $1,350. At 10 percent, commission on the $1,350 is $135.

That makes $415 in total cost.

Your gross margin on those products is 50 percent, so the $1,350 left you $675. Take away the $415 and the creator came out $260 ahead over the three months.

The break-even point is worth working out too. The product and the fee, $280 together, are fixed. Every dollar of sales after refunds leaves 50 cents of margin less 10 cents of commission, so 40 cents goes toward that $280, and the creator covers it at $700 of sales after refunds. On these numbers, anyone who brings in more than $700 over the quarter has paid for themselves.

What content is worth when sales are thin

A creator with weak sales can still be worth keeping. If they made a video you'd happily run as an ad, with their permission, think about what it would cost to have that made from scratch. That's a fair value to set beside their cost.

Sales you can't track count for something as well. Some buyers see a post and type your name into a search bar. You won't see those orders on the creator's line, but you may see sales of that product rise in the days after they post. Treat that as a reason to keep watching rather than as sales to credit to them.

What the result tells you to do

A creator well below break-even after three months, with no content you'd reuse, is one to stop paying a fee to. You can keep them on commission only, which costs you nothing unless they sell. A creator above break-even is worth more product and more attention. One well above it has earned a better personal rate, and it is better offered by you before another brand offers it.

Your biggest spend first

Start with the creator you spend most on. Pull their last three months: product sent at cost, shipping, fees, commission, and sales after refunds. Work out the margin and the break-even point the way the example does. If they're below it, have that conversation before the next parcel goes out, while there is still a change you can ask for.