How to track creator sales on Shopify
Give every creator a link that tags the visit and a code the buyer can type at checkout, then check a sample of their orders against Shopify's own record of how each buyer arrived. The link and the code each catch sales the other misses, and the sample tells you how much is still slipping through.
Two ways a sale gets tied to a creator
A link marks the visit. The buyer clicks the creator's link, the store remembers the creator, and the order that follows goes to them. A code marks the checkout: the buyer types it, usually for a discount, and the order carries it.
They fail in different places. A link loses buyers who switch devices or come back through search, and a code loses buyers who forget it and picks up strangers once it leaks. Referral link or discount code goes through both and what each costs in margin.
Open ten orders from one creator
Pick a creator who posted recently and open their last ten orders in Shopify. For each, note whether it came through the link, the code, or neither, and look at what Shopify recorded about the visit on the order page.
Say six came through the link and three through the code. The tenth carries the creator's code but arrived from a coupon site. Those nine are tracked properly, and the tenth is the start of a leak you'd otherwise have paid commission on for months.
Then do the reverse: find a few orders with no creator on them from the days after that creator posted, and check where those buyers came from. Ten orders each way takes half an hour and shows you where your tracking leaks better than any report.
What Shopify records about a visit
Shopify keeps its own record of how a customer arrived: the page they landed on and the site that sent them, where it can tell. You'll find some of it in the conversion summary on each order page, which shows the landing page and referring site of the visit where Shopify captured them, and some in Shopify's reports.
That record is your check. If an order has no creator on it but Shopify shows the visit started from a creator's link, the tag was lost on the way to checkout.
Express checkout buttons are a common place to lose it, because some skip the cart where the tag would sit. Seedr handles that case by looking at Shopify's record of the visit when the cart was never tagged, as with Buy it now, so the order can still go to the creator whose link the buyer came in on.
Read the orders labeled Direct
A good tracking setup admits what it can't see. Seedr labels a sale with nothing pointing to a source as Direct, so a creator's name only appears on an order when there's evidence for it.
Open five orders labeled Direct and check Shopify's record of the visit on each. Most will be your own customers, your emails and your ads. If several came in from a creator's link, the setup is dropping tags, and a common cause is a theme app embed that's switched off or a checkout path that skips the cart.
Don't hand out untagged sales by guesswork
When a creator posts on Tuesday and untagged sales of that product jump on Tuesday and Wednesday, the post probably drove some of them. That tells you the creator is worth more than their tracked number, which matters when you decide who to keep.
It doesn't mean you owe commission on those orders, unless your terms say so. Pay on what was tracked, and use the pattern to judge value.
Habits that keep the gaps small
A few habits cover most of the ground:
- Give every creator both a link and a code, with the discount optional.
- Use one link per creator, and don't change it once they've shared it.
- Keep creator codes and links off gifted orders, so a gift never counts as a sale.
- Write down which creator gets the sale when two of them claim the same order.
- After any theme change, place a test order through a creator link, because app embeds are switched on per theme and a new theme starts with them off.
A monthly match against your orders
Once a month, line up your tracked creator sales with your Shopify orders for the same period. Every order a creator was credited with should exist, at the same amount, and refunded orders should be marked as refunded.
If the totals don't match, find out why before you pay anyone. A tracking gap found before payday costs you an afternoon. Found after, it means asking a creator to return commission, which is a far harder message to send. Put the ten-order check on the same day each month and the two together take about an hour.