The ways to pay a creator, compared
Cash, by bank transfer or a payment service such as PayPal, suits creators who treat the work as income. Store credit and gift cards suit creators who would spend the money in your store anyway, and they cost you less. Let each creator pick, and keep a record of every payment that ties it to the sales it covers.
Bank transfer
A bank transfer puts the money where the creator wants it, with no account to open on their side. For a creator in your own country it is usually cheap and simple.
The catch is the details you have to hold. To pay by transfer you need the creator's name as the bank has it and their account details. That is sensitive information, and once you have it you are responsible for keeping it safe. Store it somewhere with a password, never in a shared sheet, and delete it when the creator leaves.
Transfers abroad are slower and can cost more, on your side and sometimes on theirs. Ask your bank for the international price before you promise one.
A payment service
With a payment service, the creator usually gives you an email address or a username rather than bank details, which leaves you less to protect. Many creators already have an account, though some won't want to open one for a small amount, so ask before you assume.
Before you offer a method, send yourself $10 through it and note what arrived. That's your real fee, for that service, those countries and that kind of payment, and it is the number to plan with.
Pay from a business account rather than your personal one, so creator payments sit apart from everything else and are easy to find at year end.
Store credit
Credit pays the creator in your own product, so it costs you what the product costs you, not its price. It suits creators who would buy from you anyway, and it should always be their choice. Offering a little more in credit than the cash balance makes the trade worth taking; paying creators in store credit works through the numbers.
Gift cards
A gift card is close to store credit, with one difference: the creator can give it away or sell it. That makes it a little more useful to them and a little less predictable for you, since the person who spends it may be a new customer or someone who would have bought anyway.
Budget a gift card as if it will be spent in full. Some cards are never redeemed, but planning on that is planning on money you may still owe.
One $200 balance, four ways
Say a creator is owed $200 this month.
By bank transfer or a payment service, it costs you $200 plus the fee your $10 test turned up.
In store credit, if the products the creator picks cost you 40 percent of their price to make and pack, $200 of credit costs you $80 in product, plus shipping when it goes out.
A $200 gift card, budgeted as spent in full, costs roughly the same $80 in product plus shipping, depending on what gets bought. If it reaches a friend who becomes a customer, you may gain a buyer as well.
Paying in credit or a card instead of cash saves you about $120 here. That saving is why the switch should come with a fair offer, such as more credit than the cash balance, and never as a quiet change to how someone gets paid.
What to record for each method
For every payment, write down who was paid, how much, on what date, and which sales or which period it covers. Then add the detail that lets you prove that payment later, which differs by method.
For a bank transfer, keep the reference your bank gives you. For a payment service, keep the transaction ID. For store credit, note the amount added and the customer account it went to. For a gift card, note the last four characters of the card and the amount.
If the cash value owed and the credit value given differ, record both. Whatever form a payment takes, record it at the amount owed, so every creator's earnings stay comparable.
You may also need paperwork from creators before you pay them at all, depending on where each of you is and how much you pay. Ask your accountant about it before the first payment rather than at year end, and ask in the same conversation how gift cards and credit should show in your books.
A short message to every creator
Ask each creator in your program how they want to be paid: transfer, a payment service, credit or a gift card. Save one method for each, run your $10 test on any service you haven't used before, and ask creators to tell you in writing if their choice changes. Use the saved method on every pay day until they do.