What to do when a commissioned order is returned
Reverse the commission on a returned order, in full for a full refund and in proportion for a partial one. To keep that painless, hold every commission until your return window has passed, so most reversals happen before anything has been paid.
Hold commission before you pay it
A hold period, part of the routine in how to pay creators commission when you pay them yourself, is the number of days you wait before a commission can be approved for payment. Return windows usually start at delivery, while the hold starts when the order is placed, so the hold has to cover the return window plus shipping time.
Say you accept returns for 30 days after delivery and parcels take up to a week to arrive. A hold of 37 days covers every return you'd accept, and 40 gives you a few days for the refund to be processed.
During the hold, the commission is earned but not yet payable. If the order is refunded in that time, the commission disappears before anyone counts it as owed. In Seedr you set the hold in days from the order date, and a commission isn't ready to approve until the hold is over, so a refund normally arrives first.
Reverse commission on a full refund
If an order is refunded in full, the commission on it goes to zero. The sale didn't happen in the end, so there's nothing to pay.
If the commission was still on hold, remove it. If it was already paid, take it off the creator's next payment instead of asking them to send money back, and note the order number so they can see why the payment is lower.
Reduce it on a partial refund
A partial refund, say one item from a three-item order, reduces the commission by the same share. If commission is figured after discounts, figure the reduction on the refunded amount after discounts too.
A creator earned 15 percent on a $90 order, or $13.50. The buyer returns a $30 item, which takes $4.50 off, and the commission settles at $9.
When the order used a code, Shopify spreads the discount across the items, so the item's refund is usually less than its list price. Work from the amount refunded for that item before tax, which is what the buyer actually paid for it.
Leave equal exchanges alone
An exchange for a different size or color at the same price isn't a lost sale, so leave the commission where it is.
If the exchange changes the value, adjust to match. A swap for something cheaper works like a partial refund. A swap for something more expensive is a bigger sale, and paying commission on the difference is up to you. Put whichever you choose in your terms so it's applied the same way every time.
Chargebacks and orders that never ship
A chargeback works like a refund for commission purposes: the money has gone back to the buyer, so the commission goes too. Chargebacks can arrive long after your return window, so decide in advance whether you'll take the amount off a later payment or absorb it.
An order you cancel before it ships should never earn commission. If your tracking records commission at checkout, make sure a cancellation reverses it the same way a refund does.
Store credit instead of a refund
When you refund a buyer in store credit, the money hasn't left your business yet. You can keep the commission, since the creator did bring in a customer who is still spending with you. Or you can reverse it and pay again when the credit is spent, which keeps commission tied to cash actually received. Both are fair if creators know which one you use.
Put the rule in writing
Write it into your program terms in plain words: how long the hold period is, that refunded orders earn no commission, how partial refunds and exchanges are handled, and what happens when a refund comes after payment. A creator who read that before their first sale won't be surprised by a smaller payout.
Match refunds before each payout
Before each pay day, pull the refunds Shopify recorded for the period and match each one to a creator sale. Shopify keeps refunds on the order, so the information is there; the work is making sure every refund reaches the commission it belongs to.
Do this before the payout. A commission corrected while it's still unpaid is a single edit, and one corrected afterwards means a deduction and an explanation.
The number for your hold
Look up your return window and your slowest delivery time, add them together, and add a few days for refunds to process. Set that as your hold period, and send creators the written rule with the next payout.