Where to find creators when your brand is small
A small brand should look for creators in places it can already see: its own customer list, the posts it has been tagged in, the comment sections of brands its buyers also follow, and accounts in its own area. People there already know the product or the category, so they say yes to a gift more readily and talk about it in their own words, and finding them costs you an hour rather than a database fee.
Search your customer list first
In Shopify, build a customer segment filtered by number of orders and last order date, for example more than one order with the latest in the past year. Anyone on that list has chosen you twice with their own money, which is a better signal than any follower count.
Turning an email address into a social account takes a little digging. Search their name on the platforms your buyers use, check whether they follow you, and look at the notes on their orders. If you send a post-purchase email, add one optional question asking for their handle. Over a few months that question builds the list for you.
You won't find everyone, and you don't need to. A handful of real fans who post regularly is a strong start.
Check who has already posted about you
Open the tagged section of your own accounts and read back through it. Then search your brand name without the @, because a person can mention a product without tagging it.
Anyone in those results has already done the thing you're hoping a creator will do, with nobody asking. Note how the post looked, how people responded to it, and whether that person posts about products often or only now and then.
Read the comments under brands like yours
Pick three or four brands your buyers also buy from that don't sell what you sell. A candle shop might look at a ceramics brand and an independent bookshop, for example.
Read the comments under their recent posts. Skip the one-word replies and look for people who write a real sentence, ask a question or share how they use the product. Click through. Some of them run accounts with an audience that looks a lot like yours.
Also look at which creators those brands repost. Before you send anything, ask whether they have an exclusive brand deal that would rule you out.
Look close to home
Local creators are easy to overlook. Search your city or region alongside your product category, check who posts about local markets and shops, and ask other small business owners nearby who they've worked with.
You can often hand a local creator the product in person, and their audience may live near your shop or your market stall. Even if you ship nationally, a nearby creator who makes good photos and videos is worth knowing.
Why fans do better than strangers at this stage
A creator you found through a search, who has never heard of you, has to be persuaded that the product is good. A customer already knows. That makes a yes more likely, and the post that follows sounds like a recommendation rather than an ad.
A fan is also more forgiving while you work things out. If a parcel is slow or your first brief is vague, someone who likes the brand tells you, and stays. A stranger with a bigger audience is more likely to expect a fee up front and move on after one post.
From 600 customers to 25 names
Say a store had 600 customers last year, and 90 of them ordered more than once. You find public accounts for 30 of those 90, and 12 of them post regularly about the kind of thing you sell.
Your tagged posts add another 8 people who aren't on the customer list. A search of local accounts adds 5 more.
That's 25 names without spending anything. With product and time for 10 gifts, you now choose the 10 who fit best from a list two and a half times that size, instead of sending to whoever you could find.
Keep the list where you'll use it
Write each name down with their handle, where you found them and one line on why they fit. Add the date you contacted them and what happened.
The "where you found them" column pays off later. After a round or two, you'll see whether your best creators came from customers, tags, comments or local search, and you can spend your hour where it works. When someone does post and you want to keep working together, a first round of seeding shows how to send product as a proper order.
Spend an hour in your tagged posts
Set a timer for one hour. Go through your tagged posts and your brand name in search, and write down every person who posted with no ask. That is the top of your first list.