Working out what gifting really costs you
What gifting really costs you is a cost per post: everything a round of gifts cost, divided by the posts that round produced. Run the same sum for each creator over several rounds and you have a cost per creator, which tells you who should get the next parcel. Both come out well above the price of the product, because the creators who never post are paid for by the ones who do.
Start from the full cost of one gift
The cost of a single gift is the product at what you paid for it, plus packaging, shipping and the time it took you. How to budget for a creator program goes through each of those lines. For the sums below, take that per gift total as known.
If you've never worked it out, time yourself on three gifts from first message to handing the parcel over, and price the box and postage on the same three. That is close enough to start.
Decide what counts as a post
Cost per post is only as good as the count underneath it, so fix the rules before you count.
Set a window, such as six weeks from the day tracking shows the parcel delivered. A post after that still counts for something, but leaving it out keeps one round from bleeding into the next.
Decide which formats count. A feed post or a video that shows the product clearly is an easy yes. A story that disappears in a day is worth counting separately, since you can't reuse it.
Count each creator's posts about one gift once, even if they post three times. You are measuring how many gifts turned into content, and a creator who posts often about one parcel would otherwise make the whole round look better than it was.
Twenty gifts, six posts
Say each gift costs you $42 in full: $15 of product, $12 of packaging and postage, and half an hour of your time at $30 an hour. You send 20 in a month, for $840.
Six creators post within the window, so each post cost you $140.
Price the same round on product alone and it looks like $300, or $50 a post. Counted properly, each post costs nearly three times that.
If only four of those six posts are good enough to reuse with permission, your cost per usable post is $210. That is the figure to compare with paying for content outright.
The same sum, one creator at a time
The monthly figure hides who is costing what. For each creator, look back over the last six months: how many gifts they had, what those cost at your per gift figure, and how many posts came back.
A creator who had three gifts and posted after each one cost you $42 a post. One who had the same three gifts and posted once cost you $126 for that post. A third who had two gifts and never posted has cost you $84 with nothing to divide it by.
Keep that history in one place, with the date each gift was delivered, or the per creator view is a guess. How to keep track of who got free product covers the record.
What the per creator figure decides
Once you can see cost per creator, the next round plans itself. Creators with a low cost per post get the next launch first. Creators who haven't posted after two gifts wait until something changes, such as a product that suits them better.
Set aside part of each round for creators you haven't gifted before, so the list keeps growing. Their first gift has no history behind it, and that is the point: it is how you find the next creator with a $42 cost per post.
Two numbers to set it beside
A cost per post means little on its own. Put it next to two other figures.
The first is what a creator would charge as a flat fee for a similar post. If gifting costs you $140 a post and a fee would be $100, gifting is the more expensive option unless the gifted posts are better or come with sales.
The second is what the gifted creators went on to sell. A round that cost $840 and found two creators who now bring in orders every month may be the best money you spent that quarter, even at $140 a post. A round that produced six posts and no sales is worth only what you can do with the content.
Your number for next month
Take last month's gifts, price one in full, and multiply by the number you sent. Divide by the posts that came back inside your window, write that cost per post at the top of next month's gifting plan, and set it beside each creator's own figure when you choose who gets a parcel.