All posts

The numbers worth watching in a creator program

Six numbers tell you how a creator program is doing: sales per creator, revenue after refunds, commission owed against commission paid, the cost of product you've sent, the share of gifted creators who post, and what each dollar of creator sales costs you. Follower counts, likes and month to month swings in a small program can wait until you have more data.

Sales per creator

Look at orders and revenue for each creator, sorted from highest to lowest, before you look at the program total. A healthy looking total can hide a program where two creators do nearly all the selling and the rest bring in a sale now and then.

That isn't a problem in itself. It tells you where to spend: more product and attention for the creators who sell, and a closer look at whether the quiet ones are posting at all. Count orders as well as revenue, since one large order can make a creator look busier than they are.

Revenue after refunds

Gross revenue flatters every creator. Take refunds off before you compare anyone, because a creator whose buyers return a lot of what they order is worth less than their gross figure says.

Commission should follow the same rule, so the figure you judge creators by and the figure you pay them on stay in step. What to do when a commissioned order is returned covers how to reverse commission when an order comes back.

Commission owed and commission paid

Keep two figures side by side: commission owed, meaning approved and waiting to be paid, and commission actually paid in the period. If the owed figure grows month after month while the paid figure stays flat, payouts are slipping.

Check the owed figure against your orders now and then too, so a missed or doubled sale is caught before it turns into a dispute. On Full, Commission audit checks the last seven days of Shopify orders against what Seedr recorded, without changing anything. Run it weekly.

The cost of product you've sent

Add up gifted product at what it cost you, plus shipping, every month. It's easy to forget, because no money changes hands with the creator, but in a young program it can be the largest cost of all.

If gifts go out as $0 orders in Shopify, the history is already there. Shopify's reports can only show what that product cost you if a cost per item is entered on each product, so check that before you rely on them.

How many gifted creators post

Divide the number of gifted creators who posted by the number you gifted. Measure it four to six weeks after the parcels arrive, since some creators take a while to try a product before they talk about it.

A low share points at who you're choosing or what you're sending. Watch it over a few rounds and see whether a change in either moves it, and keep a note of what you changed each round, such as a different kind of creator, a different product or a shorter first message. Without that note, a rise or a fall is hard to explain a few months later.

What each dollar of creator sales costs

The sixth number pulls the others together. Add commission and the cost of product sent for the month, and divide by revenue after refunds. The result is what you spent for each dollar your creators sold, and because it's a ratio, it stays comparable as the program grows.

Twenty-five gifts and $5,000 of sales

Say you gifted 25 creators last month and 10 of them posted, which is 40 percent. Creator sales came to $5,000, and refunds took off $500, leaving $4,500. At 10 percent of that, commission is $450, of which you've paid $300 so far, with $150 still owed. Each gift cost $22 in product and $6 in shipping, or $700 for the 25.

The month cost $1,150 in commission and product against $4,500 of revenue after refunds: about 26 cents for every dollar of creator sales. Of the six, that is the one to compare month to month, because it tells you whether the program is getting cheaper to run as it grows.

Numbers to leave alone at first

Follower counts tell you how big an audience is, not whether it buys from you. Likes and views are easy to collect and hard to connect to a single order. Neither belongs in your monthly numbers.

Month to month changes mislead while the program is small. With a dozen creators, one good post can double a month and one quiet creator can halve the next. Compare quarters until you have enough creators for a month to mean something.

A sheet with six rows

Open a blank sheet and fill in the six numbers for last month, even roughly: sales by creator, revenue after refunds, commission owed and paid, product cost, the share who posted, and cost per dollar of sales. Fill in a second column at the start of next month, and from then on the sheet shows the trend.