All posts

When two creators claim the same sale

Two creators end up claiming one sale when a buyer clicks one creator's link and then types another creator's code at checkout, or clicks two creators' links before buying. Pick a tie-break rule before it happens, write it into your creator terms, and apply it the same way every time. A dispute then comes down to pointing at the rule, and you never have to defend a judgment call.

How one order picks up two creators

The usual route is a link and a code from different people. A buyer watches one creator's video, clicks through, and browses. Before paying, they search for a discount, find a second creator's code on a post or a coupon site, and use it. The order now carries one creator's visit and another creator's code.

Two links can collide as well. A buyer follows two creators who both post about the same product in the same week, clicks one on Monday and the other on Thursday, and buys on Friday. Each creator can reasonably believe the sale was theirs.

In the two-link case, neither creator has done anything wrong: each did what you asked, and the buyer happened to meet both of them. A code picked up from a coupon site is a different problem, covered in what to do when a creator's code ends up on coupon sites.

The rules you can choose from

There are four rules to pick from, and each one favors something different:

  • The code wins. The creator whose code was typed at checkout gets the sale, because entering it was the buyer's last deliberate act before paying.
  • The last click wins. The most recent link clicked before the order gets the sale, on the view that it's what finally tipped the buyer.
  • The first click wins. The creator who introduced the buyer gets the sale, which rewards finding new customers over closing them.
  • Split it. Both creators get half the commission.

Code wins and last click are the simplest to apply, because the order shows the code used and the last visit's source, where Shopify can tell. First click needs a reliable record of the earliest visit, which you won't always have. Splitting sounds fairest but means two half payments to explain on every shared order, and it can still leave both creators feeling short changed.

What each rule costs you

Say an $80 order, after discounts, earns 10 percent commission, or $8. Under code wins, last click or first click, one creator gets $8 and the other gets nothing. Under a split, each gets $4. Your cost is $8 under all four.

The expensive outcome is having no rule. When both creators complain, it's tempting to pay both in full to keep the peace, and the order now costs you $16 in commission. Do that every time two creators collide and you've doubled your rate on exactly the orders where two of them were working for you.

Write the rule down

Put the rule in your creator terms in one or two plain sentences, and send it to every creator when they join. For example: "If an order has your link and another creator's code, the creator whose code was used earns the commission." A rule creators agreed to at the start is far easier to hold to than one you explain for the first time in the middle of a complaint.

Check that your tracking works the way your rule says. If your app credits the code over the link and your terms say last click, the record and the rule will disagree on every shared order. Keep the terms in line with what your tracking does, or change the tracking to match the terms. How to track creator sales on Shopify covers how links and codes each mark an order.

Handling the dispute when it comes

A creator who writes in about a missing sale usually has a reason to think it was theirs: a buyer mentioned them, or commented on their post.

Open the order in Shopify and note what it shows: the code used, if any, and where the visit came from, where Shopify can tell. Then answer from the rule. Say which creator was credited and why, in a sentence or two, and quote the line from your terms. Leave the other creator's name out unless the two already know about each other.

If you decide to make a goodwill payment anyway, record it as a one-off, separate from commission, and tell the creator that's what it is. That way it doesn't quietly become the new rule.

When the same pair keeps colliding

If two creators keep landing on the same orders, they share an audience. You might give them different products to talk about, space out their posts, or bring them together on a joint post with an agreed split. Whichever you choose, tell both of them at the same time, so neither hears it from the other first.

The sentence that settles it

Pick the rule that matches how your tracking credits orders and write it as one sentence. Add it to your creator terms, and send it to your current creators with your next payout note, so it is in place before the next shared order arrives rather than after the first complaint.